The free website to help new writers to develop, and to help talented writers get noticed and published Books
   
free-will review of my synopsis please? << Return To Main Site

 Welcome to the YouWriteOn Forum

**2012 News Random House & Orion Editors to continue free reviews of YouWriteOn Top Ten Writers each month  - publishers of many of the world's bestselling authors 

YouWriteOn Authors' Hall of Fame Congratulations to our many authors achieving sales and signings successes through  Waterstones, WHSmith and others! View Hall of Fame
     

YouWriteOn Message Board > Literary Forums > NEW - The Hopes, Dreams & Broken Schemes Forum Help Search Recent Posts
free-will review of my synopsis please?
Page 1 Last : 2 > Start New Topic Reply To Topic
perrybond
 21 Jun 2010, 12:58 #91798 Reply To Post
For the Terry Prachett competition, they need a <600 word synopsis.
see this thread about the competition.
www.youwriteon.com/forum/Pratchett-20000-writing-competition-Topic-20767-1.aspx

My novel fits and I'm un-published so I thought I'd have a go.

The book needs to be set on a realistic future/past/different version of Earth and be over 80,000 words.

This post was last edited by perrybond, 21 Jun 2010, 13:38
-
perrybond
 21 Jun 2010, 13:22 #91800 Reply To Post
Forgot to say:

Obviously I am more than happy to return the favour.

perry@hexult.com
-
perrybond
 21 Jun 2010, 13:39 #91802 Reply To Post
Hexult
Snowball Earth. The Earth is in another ice age and civilisation is restarting in a future so distant that the only traces left of our time are shards of glass.

Hexult is a group of troubled islands in the vast ice ocean, separated by the treacherous Vajra Crevasse. Aulf is the young mail man, sailing his skiff around the islands, delivering the mail, with Ingar, a half wild orphan girl, his crew. The story begins as they discover a wrecked boat on the open ice and rescue and befriend a mysterious pair of fifteen year old twins, Jacob and Elya.

The strangers’ superior knowledge of science and technology means Elya and Jacob are soon regarded by the people of Hexult as magicians. This annoys the islands’ resident wizard, Gabriel, who pursues devious ways to undermine the twins’ credibility. Jacob and Elya suggest building signal towers to improve communication and help mend the troubled relationships between the islands – wizard towers as they soon become known. To fund the project, the twins recruit Jeremiah Grimwold, a blacksmith, to produce ‘magical’ firelighters from a metal they call steel, which subsequently take the islands by storm.

Problems arise for the twins in the form of a prophecy which supposedly foretells of the twins’ coming, and links Jacob with hope and Elya with treachery. Elya soon finds herself rejected by the islanders, and relationships with her brother and her new friends are strained.

Pursued by pirates, the four friends have a close encounter with the Vajra which leaves them marooned on a tiny island, and they are rescued by a young girl and a pack of sled dogs. While Jacob makes a success of the towers, Elya becomes the target of the islanders’ superstitious prejudice and she is forced to run from a vengeful mob, mown down by pirates, and eventually rescued by Isambard, the enigmatic chieftain of the remote and wild island of Thorland, a place regarded with hostile suspicion by the rest of Hexult.

Jacob, Aulf and Ingar, unaware of Elya’s fate, grieve her loss, but, as time passes, continue building wizard towers on the other islands, and Jacob proposes the islands hold a joint ice fair. An ice tower is constructed on the open ice in preparation and great excitement surrounds the fair. Then Jacob receives an unexpected message via the tower – from Elya, who has secretly built a tower on Thorland. They arrange to reunite at the fair.

The ice fair gets off to a good start, but disaster strikes as the event is sabotaged by a pirate attack, set up by Gabriel. All seems lost until a fleet of Thorland boats unexpectedly appears on the horizon. Elya has persuaded the maligned Thorlanders to make peace with the other islands and brought them to the fair, just in time to save the day.

Elya’s return is met with hostility from the other islanders and she is put on trial for using dark magic to the detriment of the islands. Only Isambard’s intervention saves her, and she is finally reunited with Jacob, Aulf and Ingar.
-
panurge
 21 Jun 2010, 15:42 #91816 Reply To Post
Hexult
Snowball Earth. The Earth is in another ice age and civilisation is restarting in a future so distant that the only traces left of our time are shards of glass.

Hexult is a group of troubled islands in the vast ice ocean, separated by the treacherous Vajra Crevasse. Aulf is the young mail man, (Oddly specific. Would 'a young mail man' be better?) sailing his skiff around the islands, delivering the mail, (I think this comma is unecessary) with Ingar, a half wild orphan girl, his crew. (I would get rid of 'his crew'. I see your meaning, but I think it makes the sentence a little long and unwieldy) The story begins as they discover a wrecked boat on the open ice and rescue and befriend a mysterious pair of fifteen year old twins, Jacob and Elya.

The strangers’ superior knowledge of science and technology means Elya and Jacob are soon regarded by the people of Hexult as magicians. This annoys the islands’ resident wizard, Gabriel, who pursues devious ways to undermine the twins’ credibility. Jacob and Elya suggest building signal towers to improve communication and help mend the troubled relationships between the islands – wizard towers as they soon become known. To fund the project, the twins recruit Jeremiah Grimwold, a blacksmith, to produce ‘magical’ firelighters from a metal they call steel, which subsequently take the islands by storm. (Not sure about this last figure of speech. It doesn't seem to fit with the tone of the rest)

Problems arise for the twins in the form of a prophecy which supposedly foretells of the twins’ coming, (better as 'their coming' to avoid repetition?) and links Jacob with hope and Elya with treachery. Elya soon finds herself rejected by the islanders, and relationships with her brother and her new friends are strained.

Pursued by pirates, the four friends have a close encounter with the Vajra which leaves them marooned on a tiny island, and they are rescued by a young girl and a pack of sled dogs. While Jacob makes a success of the towers, Elya becomes the target of the islanders’ superstitious prejudice and she is forced to run from a vengeful mob, mown down by pirates, (is 'mown down' right? I have an odd image in my head) and eventually rescued by Isambard, the enigmatic chieftain of the remote and wild island of Thorland, a place regarded with hostile suspicion by the rest of Hexult.

Jacob, Aulf and Ingar, unaware of Elya’s fate, grieve her loss, but, as time passes, continue building wizard towers on the other islands, and Jacob proposes the islands hold a joint ice fair. An ice tower is constructed on the open ice in preparation and great excitement surrounds the fair. Then Jacob receives an unexpected message via the tower – from Elya, who has secretly built a tower on Thorland. They arrange to reunite at the fair.

The ice fair gets off to a good start, but disaster strikes as the event is sabotaged by a pirate attack, set up by Gabriel. All seems lost until a fleet of Thorland boats unexpectedly appears on the horizon. Elya has persuaded the maligned Thorlanders to make peace with the other islands and brought them to the fair, just in time to save the day.

Elya’s return is met with hostility from the other islanders and she is put on trial for using dark magic to the detriment of the islands. Only Isambard’s intervention saves her, and she is finally reunited with Jacob, Aulf and Ingar.

I've been particularly pedantic in my comments, in the hope that there will be something you can use. In terms of its content, I think this is a very good synopsis. It did engage my interest and it sells the story very well. I just think you could make it a bit snappier by breaking down some of those long sentences. Also, you might consider adding to the first paragraph to give a stronger 'hook' right at the beginning.

Hope something here is useful and good luck with the book.
The Tower of Clavius Boon
perrybond
 21 Jun 2010, 15:54 #91817 Reply To Post
Lovely, thanks, that's just what I was hoping for.
Let me know if there's anything I can do for you.

Took all your suggestions, except one.

Understand your point about the opening paragraph, but will have to go away and think what to add
This post was last edited by perrybond, 21 Jun 2010, 16:17
-
perrybond
 21 Jun 2010, 16:16 #91818 Reply To Post
Hexult
Snowball Earth. The Earth is in another ice age and civilisation is restarting in a future so distant that the only traces left of our time are shards of glass. A time where a little science goes a long way.

Hexult is a group of troubled islands in the vast ice ocean, separated by the treacherous Vajra Crevasse. Aulf is the young mail man, sailing his skiff around the islands, delivering the mail with Ingar, a half wild orphan girl. The story begins as they discover a wrecked boat on the open ice and rescue and befriend a mysterious pair of fifteen year old twins, Jacob and Elya.

The strangers’ superior knowledge of science and technology means Elya and Jacob are soon regarded by the people of Hexult as magicians. This annoys the islands’ resident wizard, Gabriel, who pursues devious ways to undermine the twins’ credibility. Jacob and Elya suggest building signal towers to improve communication and help mend the troubled relationships between the islands – wizard towers as they soon become known. To fund the project, the twins recruit Jeremiah Grimwold, a blacksmith, to produce ‘magical’ firelighters from a metal they call steel, which revolutionise the islanders lives.

Problems arise for the twins in the form of a prophecy which supposedly foretells of their coming, and links Jacob with hope and Elya with treachery. Elya soon finds herself rejected by the islanders, and relationships with her brother and her new friends are strained.

Pursued by pirates, the four friends have a close encounter with the Vajra which leaves them marooned on a tiny island, and they are rescued by a young girl and a pack of sled dogs. While Jacob makes a success of the towers, Elya becomes the target of the islanders’ superstitious prejudice and she is forced to run from a vengeful mob, captured by raiders, and eventually rescued by Isambard, the enigmatic chieftain of the remote and wild island of Thorland, a place regarded with hostile suspicion by the rest of Hexult.

Jacob, Aulf and Ingar, unaware of Elya’s fate, grieve her loss, but, as time passes, continue building wizard towers on the other islands, and Jacob proposes the islands hold a joint ice fair. An ice tower is constructed on the open ice in preparation and great excitement surrounds the fair. Then Jacob receives an unexpected message via the tower – from Elya, who has secretly built a tower on Thorland. They arrange to reunite at the fair.

The ice fair gets off to a good start, but disaster strikes as the event is sabotaged by a pirate attack, set up by Gabriel. All seems lost until a fleet of Thorland boats unexpectedly appears on the horizon. Elya has persuaded the maligned Thorlanders to make peace with the other islands and brought them to the fair, just in time to save the day.

Elya’s return is met with hostility from the other islanders and she is put on trial for using dark magic to the detriment of the islands. Only Isambard’s intervention saves her, and she is finally reunited with Jacob, Aulf and Ingar.
This post was last edited by perrybond, 21 Jun 2010, 16:20
-
panurge
 21 Jun 2010, 17:36 #91824 Reply To Post
You're welcome. I'm glad it was useful. 'Hexult' does sound very intriguing - I hope to get it as an assignment someday.
This post was last edited by panurge, 21 Jun 2010, 17:37
The Tower of Clavius Boon
timellis
 21 Jun 2010, 20:31 #91825 Reply To Post
Quote: perrybond, Monday, 21 Jun 2010 12:58
For the Terry Prachett competition, they need a <600 word synopsis.
see this thread about the competition.
www.youwriteon.com/forum/Pratchett-20000-writing-competition-Topic-20767-1.aspx

My novel fits and I'm un-published so I thought I'd have a go.

The book needs to be set on a realistic future/past/different version of Earth and be over 80,000 words.



Hi Perry!

I don't want to rain on your parade, but the rules specify a novel aimed at adult readers, and if I'm not mistaken yours is a children's novel!? Tim
perrybond
 21 Jun 2010, 21:09 #91827 Reply To Post
Ahhh. good point.
Do you think they'll notice?

More seriously
I have always had in my mind 12-14 year olds, but whenever I ask someone about age and genre I always get the same answer, find a publisher and let them worry about that.

As an adult read it's hardly challenging, but feedback for adults has always been good (and not just reading from the perspective of a children’s novel.) Whereas my attempts to teenage feedback have been a disaster.
My children and their friends all thought it was brilliant (but they have to say that, or I'd never chauffeur them anywhere). I printed 30 copies up and had a class of 10-11 year olds read it and the general feedback from the teacher was that they didn't really understand it. (These were not good readers and had problems with the basic concept of boats on the ice and what a crevasse was.)

I'm just temped to try unless someone has a good reason why I shouldn't
-
annswinfen
 22 Jun 2010, 14:26 #91854 Reply To Post
Quote: perrybond, Monday, 21 Jun 2010 21:09
Ahhh. good point.
Do you think they'll notice?

More seriously
I have always had in my mind 12-14 year olds, but whenever I ask someone about age and genre I always get the same answer, find a publisher and let them worry about that.

As an adult read it's hardly challenging, but feedback for adults has always been good (and not just reading from the perspective of a children’s novel.) Whereas my attempts to teenage feedback have been a disaster.
My children and their friends all thought it was brilliant (but they have to say that, or I'd never chauffeur them anywhere). I printed 30 copies up and had a class of 10-11 year olds read it and the general feedback from the teacher was that they didn't really understand it. (These were not good readers and had problems with the basic concept of boats on the ice and what a crevasse was.)

I'm just temped to try unless someone has a good reason why I shouldn't


I'd go ahead and submit - just don't call it a children's book!
Ann
Page 1 Last : 2 > Add To My Topic Watch List Start New Topic Reply To Topic
Server Time: 24 May 2012, 19:50

Powered by Zarr Forums

5 Database Read(s) - 0.266 seconds

 

Adverts provided by Google and not endorsed by YouWriteOn.com.