|
WendyOgden
|
|
|
|
This might be a stupid question. Bear with me I'm new here but ...
What is the point of putting writing up for feedback when it is already published?
I was about to review one and had some hopefully constructive suggestions but then realised it was already published. I've got no problem with anyone ignoring my feedback because my giving it has at least given them the opportunity to consider it. If it's too late though it does seem like a waste of time, to me, giving it.
Now I'm checking before I read. What do others think?
|
|
kazmojazz
|
|
|
|
Must admit it does put me off a little, although I have reviewed a couple and just done it exactly the same as usual. I assume the writer still wants feedback because they can alter their text somehow (no idea how though - maybe someone published can enlighten us). Otherwise, it would seem to be a bit pointless.
This post was last edited by kazmojazz, 20 Nov 2011, 13:09
|
|
WendyOgden
|
|
|
|
Thanks. Glad I'm not the only one who thinks so.
Even if you can edit published versions, it could be tricky different readers seeing different versions. Could make for an interesting discussion at a reading group if the book did well.
I suppose there is the chance that the reviewer will consider it perfect and then buy it.
|
|
LTMS1479CSP
|
|
|
|
Quote: WendyOgden, Sunday, 20 Nov 2011 12:56This might be a stupid question. Bear with me I'm new here but ... What is the point of putting writing up for feedback when it is already published? I was about to review one and had some hopefully constructive suggestions but then realised it was already published. I've got no problem with anyone ignoring my feedback because my giving it has at least given them the opportunity to consider it. If it's too late though it does seem like a waste of time, to me, giving it. Now I'm checking before I read. What do others think? Hello Wendy, I believe Kindle versions of a book are possible to edit without too much trouble. It could also be that the author is wondering what other writers think of their finished work. Maybe curiosity or maybe doubts have crept in or perhaps they want to see if they can improve on it in some way for a follow up book. Just some thoughts I had. I've no idea if this is right or not.  Catherine
|
|
WendyOgden
|
|
|
|
Thanks Catherine.
I think I'd still prefer to review works in progress but each to their own.
|
|
PJR
|
|
|
|
The first chapter of 'A Spurious Brood' is on the site, and may even be the spark that generated this thread. It's self-pubbed, printed, ebooked and available at Waterstones, Amazon etc. (and direct from me). So why is it here? Part of the answer is that I didn't know the site existed until after the book was published. I am keen to see what people think - genuine reviews are hard to generate. But the main reason is that there are two possible sequels - actually, one is a prequel - to the book. I wanted to test the market before I spend the next two years researching and writing those follow-ons. A panning for 'Spurious' on this site would have given me pause for thought. Happily that hasn't happened, tho the sample chapter was not to the taste of at least one reviewer. I have received some worthwhile advice and comment from reviewers, and I will be field testing my future writing on these pages.
Phil I read, write, bike, kayak, walk and drink Rioja - occasionally in that order. For more information go to my website
|
|
kazmojazz
|
|
|
|
Quote: PJR, Sunday, 20 Nov 2011 17:23The first chapter of 'A Spurious Brood' is on the site, and may even be the spark that generated this thread. It's self-pubbed, printed, ebooked and available at Waterstones, Amazon etc. (and direct from me). So why is it here? Part of the answer is that I didn't know the site existed until after the book was published. I am keen to see what people think - genuine reviews are hard to generate. But the main reason is that there are two possible sequels - actually, one is a prequel - to the book. I wanted to test the market before I spend the next two years researching and writing those follow-ons. A panning for 'Spurious' on this site would have given me pause for thought. Happily that hasn't happened, tho the sample chapter was not to the taste of at least one reviewer. I have received some worthwhile advice and comment from reviewers, and I will be field testing my future writing on these pages. Sounds like a perfectly good reason to me. Congratulations on the number one spot by the way.
|
|
WendyOgden
|
|
|
|
Glad it's going well for you PJR. It wasn't your book that sparked my post.
Which chart is it number one of? I'm struggling to find my way around the site.
Congrats anyway.
|
|
PJR
|
|
|
|
Gosh, Wendy, you know how to tempt a guy don't you? It's number one here Phil Quote: WendyOgden, Sunday, 20 Nov 2011 18:58Glad it's going well for you PJR. It wasn't your book that sparked my post. Which chart is it number one of? I'm struggling to find my way around the site. Congrats anyway.
Phil I read, write, bike, kayak, walk and drink Rioja - occasionally in that order. For more information go to my website
|
|
pam123writing
|
|
|
|
Quote: WendyOgden, Sunday, 20 Nov 2011 12:56This might be a stupid question. Bear with me I'm new here but ... What is the point of putting writing up for feedback when it is already published? I was about to review one and had some hopefully constructive suggestions but then realised it was already published. I've got no problem with anyone ignoring my feedback because my giving it has at least given them the opportunity to consider it. If it's too late though it does seem like a waste of time, to me, giving it. Now I'm checking before I read. What do others think? If a writer has published to Kindle they can alter their work at any given time. It may be they received reviews on Amazon that are showing a common fault and possibly they need to seek a bit more advise on revised chapters before they re-publish. Even a printed book can have a second edition with slight alterations. You can never have too much feedback, so please don't reject an assignment just because it's published. The author may genuinely be seeking a bit of help. You yourself say you had some constructive suggestions to give, so give them. They won't be wasted and you've learnt something from doing the review, plus you got a credit! I personally love to get feedback on my published work. Three Steps To Heaven'Til I Kissed YouAlways On My Mind
This post was last edited by pam123writing, 21 Nov 2011, 09:09
Three Steps to Heaven 'Til I Kissed You Always On My Mind A rock'n'roll romance series by Pam Howes all available on Amazon in paperback and e-Books. Visit my website for details. Fast Movin' Train - A stand alone love story. Amazon links on: website"And, in the end, the love you take / Is equal to the love you make." Lennon and McCartney 1969
|